We learned about William Carlos Williams earlier this week and wrote our own 16 word poems (I wrote about it here). Today we returned to WCW and studied his apology poem: This is Just to Say. I also read a few poems from Joyce Sidman’s collection of the same name. Even though the first graders in my class have been writing poems all month, stretching to write a poem of apology was challenging for many of them. They definitely knew how to say they were sorry–but that “tongue in cheek” sort of “sorry not sorry” approach eluded many of them.
With some coaching, we started to get there. Here are a couple of examples:
B wrote to his mom.
For Mom
This is just to say
I’m sorry I didn’t want to play in the baseball game
I just was as tired as a bear in winter
But it was fun playing baseball
Please forgive me mom
And this student wrote to her sister
I am sorry I came on your bed
and gave it a caterpillar look
I just wanted to give you a hug
like two bears in a cuddle
It might make me feel better
Another wrote to basketball
For Basketball
This is just to say
I’m sorry I haven’t made a shot yet.
Today stuff kept getting in my head
and I couldn’t get it out
It was like a milkshake was getting in my head
My mind said “you can do this” but
my head said I’m a brick
My own attempt was related to our first grade performance at this morning’s assembly where students sang Jimmy Buffett’s Cheeseburger in Paradise.
For Jimmy Buffett
This is just to say
I’m sorry our singing
was a bit off key
We were excited and nervous
twitching like hiccups
dressed in our cheeseburger hats and guitars
Your songs are so catchy
so fun and filled with energy
We just had to dance
and shout out with glee!